Queensland Competition Authority Amendment Bill 2018

Introduced: 15/2/2018By: Hon J Trad MPStatus: PASSED
This summary was generated by AI and has not yet been reviewed by a human.

Plain English Summary

Overview

This bill updates Queensland's rules for when businesses can access major infrastructure like rail networks, coal terminals, and ports. It aligns the state's access regime with national competition standards following reviews by the Productivity Commission and the federal Competition Policy Review, and makes the Queensland Competition Authority more accountable when processing applications.

Who it affects

Mining and resource companies seeking access to rail and port infrastructure, and the operators of that infrastructure (Aurizon Network, Queensland Rail, DBCT Management), will have clearer and more consistent rules about access declarations and pricing.

Key changes

  • Updates the four access criteria for declaring infrastructure services eligible for third-party access, aligning with national competition standards
  • Removes the standalone safety criterion from access criteria — safety can still be considered under the public interest test
  • Requires the Queensland Competition Authority to publish reasons and proposed actions on its website when it misses six-month statutory deadlines
  • Clarifies how pricing principles apply by removing conflicting references from three sections of the Act
  • Moves publication of certain notices from newspapers to the Authority's website

Bill Story

The journey of this bill through Parliament, including debate and recorded votes.

Introduced15 Feb 2018View Hansard
First Reading15 Feb 2018View Hansard
Committee15 Feb 2018View Hansard

Referred to Economics and Governance Committee

Committee Findings
Recommended passage

The Economics and Governance Committee examined the bill over one month, receiving four submissions and holding a public hearing on 5 March 2018. The committee recommended the bill be passed, finding general stakeholder support for aligning Queensland's third party access regime with the national access regime. Some stakeholders raised concerns about the timing of changes relative to upcoming declaration reviews for the Central Queensland Coal Network and Dalrymple Bay Coal Terminal, but Queensland Treasury advised that the reforms provided necessary regulatory clarity.

Key findings (5)
  • The bill aligns Queensland's third party access criteria with the national access regime, following recommendations by the Productivity Commission
  • Stakeholders broadly supported the changes to access declaration criteria, including Aurizon Network and the Queensland Resources Council
  • The Queensland Resources Council and Dalrymple Bay Coal Terminal User Group raised concerns that introducing new criteria during upcoming declaration reviews (expiring in 2020) could create investment uncertainty
  • Aurizon Network raised concerns that changes to pricing principle provisions could undermine the ability of infrastructure operators to recover efficient costs
  • Queensland Treasury advised that the changes clarify rather than alter the application of pricing principles and that no practical benefit would arise from legislatively extending existing declarations
Recommendations (1)
  • The committee recommends the Queensland Competition Authority Amendment Bill 2018 be passed.
AI-generated summary — may contain errors
Committee Report15 Mar 2018

Committee report tabled

Second Reading21 Mar 2018View Hansard
14 members spoke14 support
11.15 amMr PERRETTSupports

Spoke in support of the bill while emphasising the hypocrisy of Labor introducing competition legislation for infrastructure it privatised, and cautioned that effective competition policy administration is critical for Queensland's most productive industries.

While I do not oppose the bill, it is important that we are highly vigilant in how we administer and manage competition policy because it has a significant impact on the outcomes for some of our most productive industry sectors.2018-03-22View Hansard
4.23 pmHon. JA TRADSupports

Moved the second reading as Treasurer, explaining the bill updates the access regime to restore the natural monopoly test following a High Court decision, improve QCA accountability, and align with the national access regime.

The result of the entire package of changes in the bill will be improved processes under the QCA Act and greater regulatory certainty, improving investment certainty and bringing benefits to the Queensland economy.2018-03-21View Hansard
11.21 amMr RUSSOSupports

Supported the bill as necessary to align Queensland's access regime with national standards and ensure positive investment incentives in significant infrastructure.

Regulatory certainty is a key issue in regulated industries. The amended access criteria are intended to be in place for the authority's pre-expiry review of existing declarations under Queensland's access regime.2018-03-22View Hansard
4.31 pmMr MANDERSupports

Confirmed the LNP would not oppose the bill but criticised Labor for selling the assets that necessitated the regime, and raised Aurizon's concerns about pricing principles.

As per the committee's recommendation, the LNP will not be opposing the Queensland Competition Authority Amendment Bill 2018.2018-03-21View Hansard
11.26 amMr POWELLSupports

Supported the bill and the principle of third-party access regimes for monopoly infrastructure, while criticising Labor for privatising the assets that now require competition regulation.

The last thing we want is to create a pricing determination on this significant infrastructure such that it creates an anomaly in the ability of businesses to have the money in their companies to maintain and improve that facility.2018-03-22View Hansard
4.42 pmMr POWERSupports

Spoke as committee chair, explaining the bill prevents inefficient duplication of monopoly infrastructure and noting the committee unanimously recommended passage without reservation.

The committee recommended that the Queensland Competition Authority Amendment Bill 2018 be passed. We did so without any statement of reservation or any further recommendations.2018-03-21View Hansard
11.36 amMr BUTCHERSupports

Supported the bill as demonstrating the government's commitment to the resources industry and ensuring competitive access to critical infrastructure including ports in his electorate.

The Queensland Competition Authority Amendment Bill 2018 being debated here proves the Palaszczuk government's commitment to the resources industry in Queensland.2018-03-22View Hansard
4.52 pmMr STEVENSSupports

Supported the bill as a committee member, noting it brings Queensland into line with the national access regime and addresses natural monopoly concerns, while acknowledging stakeholder concerns about regulatory uncertainty.

The committee was unanimous in its support for the passing of this bill after due and proper consideration.2018-03-21View Hansard
11.42 amDr ROWANSupports

Supported the bill's objectives to align Queensland's access regime with national standards while criticising Labor for selling the infrastructure assets that necessitate such regulation.

We would not have to worry about private companies taking advantage of monopoly infrastructure if the Labor Party had not sold off Queensland's assets.2018-03-22View Hansard
5.01 pmMs BOYDSupports

Supported the bill, emphasising the importance of consistency between Queensland's and the national access regime before the QCA's upcoming pre-expiry review of declarations.

It is imperative that there is consistency between Queensland's access regime and the national access regime.2018-03-21View Hansard
11.49 amMr NICHOLLSSupports

Supported the bill as the LNP supports competition in all spheres, but raised concerns about six-month time frames on QCA decisions and the risk of large corporates gaming the system with overwhelming submissions.

The LNP will be supporting this bill because we in the LNP support competition. We want to see more competition in all spheres.2018-03-22View Hansard
5.06 pmMr MILLARSupports

Supported the bill, highlighting the significant economic impact of the Central Queensland coal network and Dalrymple Bay Coal Terminal on regional communities, while raising concerns about freight network certainty in Western Queensland.

The rail transport services provided to the Aurizon network's Central Queensland coal network are important, as are the coal-handling services to the Dalrymple Bay Coal Terminal. They are very important to the Queensland economy.2018-03-21View Hansard
11.59 amHon. JA TRADSupports

As Deputy Premier and Treasurer, spoke in reply defending the bill and emphasising that monopoly infrastructure requires regulation whether publicly or privately owned, and that Queensland is leading the way as the first state to align with national access regime changes.

Whether it is public or whether it is private, it is monopolistic infrastructure and it needs to be run competitively and people need to have access to it.2018-03-22View Hansard
5.12 pmMr MADDENSupports

Supported the bill, explaining the amendments restore the natural monopoly test changed by a 2012 High Court decision and strengthen QCA accountability for meeting decision timeframes.

The amendment proposed in the bill will return the interpretation of this criterion back to its previous 'natural monopoly' test, rather than a test that considers whether it is profitable for anyone to develop another facility.2018-03-21View Hansard
In Detail22 Mar 2018View Hansard
Amendment

That the amendment be agreed to

Division unrelated to the Queensland Competition Authority Amendment Bill debate, which was adjourned at the end of this sitting day.

Defeated39 ayes – 52 noes2018-03-21

The motion was defeated.

Show individual votes

Ayes (39)

Bates(Liberal National Party)
Batt(Liberal National Party)
Bennett(Liberal National Party)
Bleijie(Liberal National Party)
Boothman(Liberal National Party)
Boyce(Liberal National Party)
Costigan(North Queensland First)
Crandon(Liberal National Party)
Crisafulli(Liberal National Party)
Frecklington(Liberal National Party)
Hart(Liberal National Party)
Hunt(Liberal National Party)
Janetzki(Liberal National Party)
Krause(Liberal National Party)
Langbroek(Liberal National Party)
Last(Liberal National Party)
Leahy(Liberal National Party)
Lister(Liberal National Party)
Mander(Liberal National Party)
McArdle(Liberal National Party)
McDonald(Liberal National Party)
Mickelberg(Liberal National Party)
Millar(Liberal National Party)
Minnikin(Liberal National Party)
Molhoek(Liberal National Party)
Nicholls(Liberal National Party)
O’Connor(Liberal National Party)
Perrett(Liberal National Party)
Powell(Liberal National Party)
Purdie(Liberal National Party)
Robinson(Liberal National Party)
Rowan(Liberal National Party)
Simpson(Liberal National Party)
Sorensen(Liberal National Party)
Stevens(Liberal National Party)
Stuckey(Liberal National Party)
Watts(Liberal National Party)
Weir(Liberal National Party)
Wilson(Liberal National Party)

Noes (52)

Andrew(One Nation Party)
B. O’Rourke(Australian Labor Party)
Bailey(Australian Labor Party)
Bolton(Independent)
Boyd(Australian Labor Party)
Brown(Australian Labor Party)
Butcher(Australian Labor Party)
C. O’Rourke(Australian Labor Party)
Crawford(Australian Labor Party)
Dametto(Katter's Australian Party)
Dick(Australian Labor Party)
D’Ath(Australian Labor Party)
Enoch(Australian Labor Party)
Farmer(Australian Labor Party)
Fentiman(Australian Labor Party)
Furner(Australian Labor Party)
Gilbert(Australian Labor Party)
Grace(Australian Labor Party)
Harper(Australian Labor Party)
Healy(Australian Labor Party)
Hinchliffe(Australian Labor Party)
Howard(Australian Labor Party)
Jones(Australian Labor Party)
Katter(Katter's Australian Party)
Kelly(Australian Labor Party)
King
Knuth(Katter's Australian Party)
Lauga(Australian Labor Party)
Linard(Australian Labor Party)
Lui(Australian Labor Party)
Lynham(Australian Labor Party)
Madden(Australian Labor Party)
McMahon(Australian Labor Party)
McMillan(Australian Labor Party)
Mellish(Australian Labor Party)
Miles(Australian Labor Party)
Miller(Australian Labor Party)
Mullen(Australian Labor Party)
Palaszczuk(Australian Labor Party)
Pease(Australian Labor Party)
Pegg(Australian Labor Party)
Power(Australian Labor Party)
Pugh(Australian Labor Party)
Richards(Australian Labor Party)
Russo(Australian Labor Party)
Ryan(Australian Labor Party)
Saunders(Australian Labor Party)
Scanlon(Australian Labor Party)
Stewart(Australian Labor Party)
Trad(Australian Labor Party)
Whiting(Australian Labor Party)
de Brenni(Australian Labor Party)

That the motion, as amended, be agreed to

Division unrelated to the Queensland Competition Authority Amendment Bill debate, which was adjourned at the end of this sitting day.

Passed48 ayes – 43 noes2018-03-21

The motion passed.

Show individual votes

Ayes (48)

B. O’Rourke(Australian Labor Party)
Bailey(Australian Labor Party)
Bolton(Independent)
Boyd(Australian Labor Party)
Brown(Australian Labor Party)
Butcher(Australian Labor Party)
C. O’Rourke(Australian Labor Party)
Crawford(Australian Labor Party)
Dick(Australian Labor Party)
D’Ath(Australian Labor Party)
Enoch(Australian Labor Party)
Farmer(Australian Labor Party)
Fentiman(Australian Labor Party)
Furner(Australian Labor Party)
Gilbert(Australian Labor Party)
Grace(Australian Labor Party)
Harper(Australian Labor Party)
Healy(Australian Labor Party)
Hinchliffe(Australian Labor Party)
Howard(Australian Labor Party)
Jones(Australian Labor Party)
Kelly(Australian Labor Party)
King
Lauga(Australian Labor Party)
Linard(Australian Labor Party)
Lui(Australian Labor Party)
Lynham(Australian Labor Party)
Madden(Australian Labor Party)
McMahon(Australian Labor Party)
McMillan(Australian Labor Party)
Mellish(Australian Labor Party)
Miles(Australian Labor Party)
Miller(Australian Labor Party)
Mullen(Australian Labor Party)
Palaszczuk(Australian Labor Party)
Pease(Australian Labor Party)
Pegg(Australian Labor Party)
Power(Australian Labor Party)
Pugh(Australian Labor Party)
Richards(Australian Labor Party)
Russo(Australian Labor Party)
Ryan(Australian Labor Party)
Saunders(Australian Labor Party)
Scanlon(Australian Labor Party)
Stewart(Australian Labor Party)
Trad(Australian Labor Party)
Whiting(Australian Labor Party)
de Brenni(Australian Labor Party)

Noes (43)

Andrew(One Nation Party)
Bates(Liberal National Party)
Batt(Liberal National Party)
Bennett(Liberal National Party)
Bleijie(Liberal National Party)
Boothman(Liberal National Party)
Boyce(Liberal National Party)
Costigan(North Queensland First)
Crandon(Liberal National Party)
Crisafulli(Liberal National Party)
Dametto(Katter's Australian Party)
Frecklington(Liberal National Party)
Hart(Liberal National Party)
Hunt(Liberal National Party)
Janetzki(Liberal National Party)
Katter(Katter's Australian Party)
Knuth(Katter's Australian Party)
Krause(Liberal National Party)
Langbroek(Liberal National Party)
Last(Liberal National Party)
Leahy(Liberal National Party)
Lister(Liberal National Party)
Mander(Liberal National Party)
McArdle(Liberal National Party)
McDonald(Liberal National Party)
Mickelberg(Liberal National Party)
Millar(Liberal National Party)
Minnikin(Liberal National Party)
Molhoek(Liberal National Party)
Nicholls(Liberal National Party)
O’Connor(Liberal National Party)
Perrett(Liberal National Party)
Powell(Liberal National Party)
Purdie(Liberal National Party)
Robinson(Liberal National Party)
Rowan(Liberal National Party)
Simpson(Liberal National Party)
Sorensen(Liberal National Party)
Stevens(Liberal National Party)
Stuckey(Liberal National Party)
Watts(Liberal National Party)
Weir(Liberal National Party)
Wilson(Liberal National Party)
1 procedural vote

Vote to grant leave

Procedural vote on a matter unrelated to the Queensland Competition Authority Amendment Bill. The bill itself passed on voices without a recorded division.

Defeated40 ayes – 47 noes2018-03-22

Permission was refused.

A vote on whether to grant permission — for example, to introduce an amendment or vary normal procedure.

Show individual votes

Ayes (40)

Bates(Liberal National Party)
Batt(Liberal National Party)
Bennett(Liberal National Party)
Berkman(Queensland Greens)
Bleijie(Liberal National Party)
Bolton(Independent)
Boothman(Liberal National Party)
Boyce(Liberal National Party)
Costigan(North Queensland First)
Crisafulli(Liberal National Party)
Frecklington(Liberal National Party)
Hart(Liberal National Party)
Hunt(Liberal National Party)
Janetzki(Liberal National Party)
Krause(Liberal National Party)
Langbroek(Liberal National Party)
Last(Liberal National Party)
Leahy(Liberal National Party)
Lister(Liberal National Party)
Mander(Liberal National Party)
McArdle(Liberal National Party)
McDonald(Liberal National Party)
Mickelberg(Liberal National Party)
Millar(Liberal National Party)
Minnikin(Liberal National Party)
Molhoek(Liberal National Party)
Nicholls(Liberal National Party)
O’Connor(Liberal National Party)
Perrett(Liberal National Party)
Powell(Liberal National Party)
Purdie(Liberal National Party)
Robinson(Liberal National Party)
Rowan(Liberal National Party)
Simpson(Liberal National Party)
Sorensen(Liberal National Party)
Stevens(Liberal National Party)
Stuckey(Liberal National Party)
Watts(Liberal National Party)
Weir(Liberal National Party)
Wilson(Liberal National Party)

Noes (47)

B. O’Rourke(Australian Labor Party)
Bailey(Australian Labor Party)
Boyd(Australian Labor Party)
Brown(Australian Labor Party)
Butcher(Australian Labor Party)
C. O’Rourke(Australian Labor Party)
Crawford(Australian Labor Party)
Dick(Australian Labor Party)
D’Ath(Australian Labor Party)
Enoch(Australian Labor Party)
Farmer(Australian Labor Party)
Fentiman(Australian Labor Party)
Furner(Australian Labor Party)
Gilbert(Australian Labor Party)
Grace(Australian Labor Party)
Harper(Australian Labor Party)
Healy(Australian Labor Party)
Hinchliffe(Australian Labor Party)
Howard(Australian Labor Party)
Jones(Australian Labor Party)
Kelly(Australian Labor Party)
King
Lauga(Australian Labor Party)
Linard(Australian Labor Party)
Lui(Australian Labor Party)
Lynham(Australian Labor Party)
Madden(Australian Labor Party)
McMahon(Australian Labor Party)
McMillan(Australian Labor Party)
Mellish(Australian Labor Party)
Miles(Australian Labor Party)
Miller(Australian Labor Party)
Mullen(Australian Labor Party)
Palaszczuk(Australian Labor Party)
Pease(Australian Labor Party)
Pegg(Australian Labor Party)
Power(Australian Labor Party)
Pugh(Australian Labor Party)
Richards(Australian Labor Party)
Russo(Australian Labor Party)
Ryan(Australian Labor Party)
Saunders(Australian Labor Party)
Scanlon(Australian Labor Party)
Stewart(Australian Labor Party)
Trad(Australian Labor Party)
Whiting(Australian Labor Party)
de Brenni(Australian Labor Party)
Third Reading22 Mar 2018View Hansard
Royal Assent — Act 6 of 20181 May 2018View Hansard

Assent date: 29 March 2018