Health Legislation Amendment Bill 2025
Plain English Summary
Overview
This bill puts frontline clinicians onto Queensland's Hospital and Health Boards and strengthens enforcement against illegal vaping. It requires each hospital board to include at least one doctor, nurse, or allied health professional who works at that hospital, and it allows seized vaping goods to be immediately destroyed rather than stored for weeks in expensive, hazardous conditions.
Who it affects
Hospital patients benefit from clinical voices in hospital governance. Illegal vaping operators face swifter seizure of goods and potential court orders to repay enforcement costs. Legitimate retailers and pharmacies are not targeted.
Key changes
- Each Hospital and Health Board must include at least one registered clinician employed by the local health service for at least 8 hours per week over 2 years
- HHS clinician board members cannot be appointed as Chair or Deputy Chair of the board
- Seized vaping goods can be immediately forfeited and destroyed without a 28-day show cause period
- Courts can order convicted tobacco and vaping offenders to repay the State's costs for testing, storing, destroying seized goods, investigating offences, and preparing prosecutions
- Compensation remains available through the courts if vaping goods are wrongly seized and destroyed
Bill Story
The journey of this bill through Parliament, including debate and recorded votes.
▸Committee14 Mar 2025View Hansard
Referred to Health, Environment and Innovation Committee
5 members · Chair: Robert Molhoek
The Health, Environment and Innovation Committee examined the bill, receiving 12 submissions and holding a public hearing. The committee recommended the bill be passed. The bill requires at least one member of each Hospital and Health Board to be a clinician employed by the relevant Hospital and Health Service, and amends the Tobacco and Other Smoking Products Act to allow expedited forfeiture and destruction of seized vaping goods and cost recovery from convicted offenders. Labor and Greens members filed a statement of reservation raising concerns about conflicts of interest and vaping waste disposal.
Key findings (5)
- Stakeholders strongly supported requiring a frontline clinician on each Hospital and Health Board to ensure decisions are informed by direct patient care experience
- The Queensland Integrity Commissioner advised that conflicts of interest from appointing HHS employees to their own board could be complex to manage but existing statutory disclosure requirements are adequate
- Since October 2024, Queensland Health has seized over 150,000 illicit vapes worth more than $5 million, creating unsustainable storage challenges due to fire hazards and hazardous materials
- The committee carefully analysed the removal of the show cause process for vaping goods forfeiture, finding it justified given the safety risks and the ease of identifying illicit vaping products
- Submitters raised concerns about the classification of vaping products as pharmaceutical waste and the lack of a safe disposal pathway in Queensland
Recommendations (1)
- The committee recommends that the Bill be passed.
Committee report tabled
▸Second Reading12 June 2025View Hansard
▸17 members spoke9 support8 mixed
As minister, introduced the bill delivering on the election commitment to put frontline clinicians on hospital boards and strengthen enforcement against illegal vaping products.
“This bill delivers pragmatic, considered reforms to support stronger governance and improved public health outcomes.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
As shadow minister, supported the vaping enforcement measures but opposed Part 2 (hospital board amendments), arguing they create governance conflicts of interest and are political posturing rather than genuine reform. Announced Labor would vote to pass the bill except for Part 2.
“We will vote to pass the bill, except for the amendments contained in part 2. We do not have an objection to the late amendments from the minister, but the government should go back to the drawing board.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
As committee chair, supported both components of the bill. Noted the Integrity Commissioner advised no concerns with conflict management and highlighted the vaping crisis among Queensland students.
“Between 2017 and 2023, the rate of vaping amongst Queensland high school students has tripled—tripled—and we know from the Cancer Council that young people who vape are 29 times more likely to start smoking traditional cigarettes.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Opposed Part 2 as a former nurse, arguing clinicians are already in charge of hospitals and the bill creates unnecessary governance conflicts. Supported the vaping enforcement measures.
“I want to categorically reject this notion that nurses and doctors are not in charge of hospitals. It is a cheap political statement.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported both components of the bill, emphasising the importance of frontline clinician representation on hospital boards and the need to crack down on illegal vaping.
“This legislation makes amendments to two key pieces of health law... These are smart, targeted changes that respond to genuine frontline feedback and deliver practical outcomes for Queenslanders.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported the bill, drawing on personal experience of an aunt who worked as a nurse for over 25 years. Backed both the clinician board appointment reforms and the vaping enforcement measures.
“Under the amendments to the Hospital and Health Boards Act, every hospital and health board in Queensland will include at least one frontline clinician, someone actively working in direct patient care.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported the vaping enforcement measures but opposed Part 2, citing the Integrity Commissioner's concerns about governance conflicts. Argued the amendment does not deliver real-world benefits for patient outcomes.
“In the overall scheme of things, this amendment does not deliver any real-world benefits when it comes to patient outcomes. It does not reduce elective surgery wait times or emergency wait times.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported the bill, emphasising the need for frontline clinician voices on boards particularly in regional areas and highlighting the vaping enforcement results in Rockhampton.
“During my campaign I spoke with countless hospital practitioners who expressed frustration at the disconnect between board and executive decisions and the realities of frontline health care.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Strongly supported the vaping enforcement measures, comparing vapes to cane toads as a solution that became its own problem. Noted concerns with other aspects of the bill but focused on vaping.
“In more ways than one, vapes are a bit like cane toads. We all know that cane toads were introduced to Queensland to rid us of the terrible problem of cane beetles. How did that go?”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported the bill, praising the performance of Maryborough Hospital staff and backing the clinician board appointment and vaping enforcement measures.
“This is a practical, meaningful reform. It ensures people who understand the system from the inside are shaping the services their communities rely on.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported the bill as a regional member, highlighting the challenges of small hospitals like Sarina (21 beds) and Mount Morgan (9 beds) and the need for local voices on boards.
“Those who work on the front line know our health system better than anyone: they live it every day. They see the challenges firsthand.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Opposed Part 2 as a lazy election commitment that creates governance conflicts highlighted by the Integrity Commissioner. Supported the vaping enforcement measures, drawing on personal experience of her father's lung cancer from heavy smoking.
“If the Integrity Commissioner is questioning the legitimacy and ethical standards of these amendments then how can the Crisafulli government move in good faith to proceed with this bill?”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported the bill, highlighting her years of advocacy against illegal chop-chop shops in Mudgeeraba and the immediate impact of the government's enforcement actions.
“Since the Crisafulli LNP government was elected, Queensland Health has seized more than 250,000 vapes, with Queensland Health spearheading the largest seizure of illegal cigarettes and vapes by any health authority in Australia.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported the vaping enforcement measures but opposed Part 2 as a political stunt, arguing boards already have clinicians under section 23(3) and the bill creates serious conflict of interest risks.
“Under the current law, boards already have clinicians. Section 23(3) of the act requires it... In fact, 13 out of the 16 hospital and health services already have clinicians in some of the most senior positions.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported the bill, highlighting the alarming vaping statistics and enforcement results. Shared stories of legitimate businesses in Callide impacted by illegal vape and tobacco trade.
“I have been contacted by many businesses across the electorate of Callide that are legitimate businesses... These businesses and law-abiding citizens have been heavily impacted by this illegal trade.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported the vaping enforcement measures but opposed Part 2. Rebutted government claims about removing clinical experience, arguing the amendments create governance complications.
“The best way to ensure that people of experience can remain in the health system is to ensure that they have a place there—that they have the full-time jobs to provide that service.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
Supported vaping enforcement but opposed Part 2 as a kneejerk reaction and political stunt. Cited the Integrity Commissioner's concerns about conflicts of interest and argued the existing act already requires clinician board members.
“The opposition supports certain parts of this bill, particularly the measures aimed at combatting illegal vaping... Unfortunately, we cannot support part 2 of the bill, which amends the composition requirements of hospital and health boards.”— 2025-06-12View Hansard
▸In Detail11 June 2025 – 12 June 2025View Hansard
Government amendment inserting a new Part 2A amending the Pharmacy Business Ownership Act 2024 to clarify employment terms and conditions for staff transferring from Queensland Health to the newly established Queensland Pharmacy Business Ownership Council, preserving their entitlements.
▸1 clause vote (all passed)
That clauses 3 to 8, as read, stand part of the bill
Vote on whether to retain Part 2 of the bill, which requires at least one hospital and health board member to be an employee clinician of the HHS. The ALP opposed these clauses arguing they created governance conflicts of interest while existing law already required clinicians on boards. The LNP voted in favour to deliver their election commitment.
The motion passed.
▸Show individual votesHide individual votes
Ayes (47)
Noes (30)
Referenced Entities
Legislation
Programs & Schemes
Sectors Affected
Classified using AGIFT/ANZSIC Australian government standards